Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Jfdlsjfd" data-source="post: 9268658" data-attributes="member: 42856">If I do an image from scratch using my pencil, and I digitize it and I notice a few blotches of ink and tell the AI &quot;remove the inkstain&quot; (a possible use of the AI program called llama-cleaner), should the result be &quot;AI art&quot; and fail the test, or should the result be &quot;human-made&quot; and pass the test?Do you intend to detect 100% made AI art only without human intervention? Do you intend to detect accurately only &quot;low effort AI art&quot; (prompt typed in a common online generation website) or more involved process based on an initially generated image, that was later modified and improved, possibly with AI tools? (which I guess would be most AI-art being professionally made).The answer to these will give different answers to your question, ranging for &quot;incohrent number of fingers&quot; (which was a good sign to tell low-effort generations, because while you're right that humans can be bad at drawing hands, there is a small chance they'd be able to draw perfect hands... and yet make it with six fingers on the left hand and four on the right hand, as AI often do) to the more involved one I proposed earlier.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Jfdlsjfd, post: 9268658, member: 42856"] If I do an image from scratch using my pencil, and I digitize it and I notice a few blotches of ink and tell the AI "remove the inkstain" (a possible use of the AI program called llama-cleaner), should the result be "AI art" and fail the test, or should the result be "human-made" and pass the test? Do you intend to detect 100% made AI art only without human intervention? Do you intend to detect accurately only "low effort AI art" (prompt typed in a common online generation website) or more involved process based on an initially generated image, that was later modified and improved, possibly with AI tools? (which I guess would be most AI-art being professionally made). The answer to these will give different answers to your question, ranging for "incohrent number of fingers" (which was a good sign to tell low-effort generations, because while you're right that humans can be bad at drawing hands, there is a small chance they'd be able to draw perfect hands... and yet make it with six fingers on the left hand and four on the right hand, as AI often do) to the more involved one I proposed earlier. [/QUOTE]

Verification