Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="The Firebird" data-source="post: 9832794" data-attributes="member: 7015803">I think these are some of the best examples offered. From my perspective, it feels like they don't land because the more pro-AI position is &quot;AI is capable of doing some things well&quot;. The counterargument reads to me (have I got it wrong?) as &quot;AI is not capable of doing things well, see these n examples&quot;.And it doesn't convince me because we have all seen many many examples of AI doing things poorly. But those type of examples cannot establish that AI is not capable of doing things well. Just that it often or occasionally does things poorly.I see the same disconnect in the exchange between [USER=6182]@Incenjucar[/USER] and [USER=7026617]@Thomas Shey[/USER]. I'm sure Incenjucar is seeing a lot of bad examples of AI use where it distorts the facts or changes the meaning. But that can't contradict Thomas Shey seeing examples where it doesn't.If I've mischaracterized the anti-AI argument, then I apologize and would appreciate being corrected.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="The Firebird, post: 9832794, member: 7015803"] I think these are some of the best examples offered. From my perspective, it feels like they don't land because the more pro-AI position is "AI is capable of doing some things well". The counterargument reads to me (have I got it wrong?) as "AI is not capable of doing things well, see these n examples". And it doesn't convince me because we have all seen many many examples of AI doing things poorly. But those type of examples cannot establish that AI is not capable of doing things well. Just that it often or occasionally does things poorly. I see the same disconnect in the exchange between [USER=6182]@Incenjucar[/USER] and [USER=7026617]@Thomas Shey[/USER]. I'm sure Incenjucar is seeing a lot of bad examples of AI use where it distorts the facts or changes the meaning. But that can't contradict Thomas Shey seeing examples where it doesn't. If I've mischaracterized the anti-AI argument, then I apologize and would appreciate being corrected. [/QUOTE]

Verification