Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Flamestrike" data-source="post: 8493042" data-attributes="member: 6788736">Where is that rule in the PHB?Can you direct me to it?Great, but that's not how the rules work.You can rule however you want at your table though. I'm not stopping you.No, you're wrong. This has been covered a billion times already, including by the dude that wrote the rules who clearly states you're wrong, in a tweet, sage advice and on a podcast.You're not following the rules.The Rogue remains hidden until the attack is resolved, hit or miss. Says so in the PHB, as confirmed by JC in multiple sources.That's because those are the rules.Bill, you're wrong by the Rules. That's all Im saying here.Im not questioning your ruling (go crazy with how you do it at your table, I dont play at it). Im just pointing out that the rules as written do not support your interpretation, and what you posted are not the actual rules for how hiding works.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Flamestrike, post: 8493042, member: 6788736"] Where is that rule in the PHB? Can you direct me to it? Great, but that's not how the rules work. You can rule however you want at your table though. I'm not stopping you. No, you're wrong. This has been covered a billion times already, including by the dude that wrote the rules who clearly states you're wrong, in a tweet, sage advice and on a podcast. You're not following the rules. The Rogue remains hidden until the attack is resolved, hit or miss. Says so in the PHB, as confirmed by JC in multiple sources. That's because those are the rules. Bill, you're wrong by the Rules. That's all Im saying here. Im not questioning your ruling (go crazy with how you do it at your table, I dont play at it). Im just pointing out that the rules as written do not support your interpretation, and what you posted are not the actual rules for how hiding works. [/QUOTE]

Verification