Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sunseeker" data-source="post: 6289811">I try not to be snarky with my players, which honestly that's how that comes off sounding.&nbsp; If something states that my character gains specific knowledge, they gain specific knowledge.&nbsp; If the ability did not say they gained specific knowledge, I wouldn't give them specifics.&nbsp; I think it's rather rude to give vague information when the game instructs otherwise.&nbsp; That said, I don't like the ability, but I went with it as it's not detrimental to the game overall, just to the temporary immersion.Of course, if &quot;damage&quot; was measured in more RP terms, ie: An attack &quot;injures&quot; the target, a successful follow-up attack moves that up to &quot;seriously injured&quot; and then &quot;wounded&quot; and &quot;crippled&quot; and so on (which frankly might be a cool system), I would have less trouble with an ability to gave a player specific knowledge, because the knowledge itsself is not specific.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sunseeker, post: 6289811"] I try not to be snarky with my players, which honestly that's how that comes off sounding. If something states that my character gains specific knowledge, they gain specific knowledge. If the ability did not say they gained specific knowledge, I wouldn't give them specifics. I think it's rather rude to give vague information when the game instructs otherwise. That said, I don't like the ability, but I went with it as it's not detrimental to the game overall, just to the temporary immersion. Of course, if "damage" was measured in more RP terms, ie: An attack "injures" the target, a successful follow-up attack moves that up to "seriously injured" and then "wounded" and "crippled" and so on (which frankly might be a cool system), I would have less trouble with an ability to gave a player specific knowledge, because the knowledge itsself is not specific. [/QUOTE]

Verification