Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mephista" data-source="post: 6543400" data-attributes="member: 6786252">It should be noted that Hoard Breaker and Giant Killer both provide third attacks as well. Colossus Slayer deals an extra 1d8 a turn, an average of 4.5 damage for the least powerful option of the Hunter class. The hawk deals 1 damage on a hit. The mastiff 4 damage. The panther 5.  +2 from proficency bonus, and half it for the average chance to hit.  Meanwhile, the Colossus Slayer feature will trigger automatically, making it a given.   So, 1.5/3/3.5 versus 4.5 extra dpr a turn. They seem pretty balanced to me so far.   I'm all ears for how that's overpowered.   I'm seeing people react to the idea of "a third attack" being broken/wrong.   Given the average damage we're talking, I'm not impressed.    There's nothing "straight overpowered" about an extra 3 damage a turn.</blockquote>