Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="prosfilaes" data-source="post: 5642534" data-attributes="member: 40166">Sure you have reason not to believe him. He's no longer your trusted friend and ally; you did something you wouldn't have done without without magic; it doesn't take much paranoia to conclude that the wizard used magic to make you do that.Yes, because there are no T-rex on my world. Context is king.Nobody is going to stop in the middle of an argument to cast alarm. If he was calling a demon to hurt them, killing him was justified. And again, it's not about whether the fighter could have known with certainty what the spell was, but whether a little paranoia could have made the guess. In any jurisdiction that recognizes magic, casting a spell on an unwilling target would be battery. It's a little more complex, since he didn't own the item, but that could make this robbery which is 25 to life in California, not counting any aggravating factors of using mind-controlling magic (which would be at least equal to that of using a gun.)So what? It doesn't make him a metagamer, nor does it mean that what was done to him was fair.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="prosfilaes, post: 5642534, member: 40166"] Sure you have reason not to believe him. He's no longer your trusted friend and ally; you did something you wouldn't have done without without magic; it doesn't take much paranoia to conclude that the wizard used magic to make you do that. Yes, because there are no T-rex on my world. Context is king. Nobody is going to stop in the middle of an argument to cast alarm. If he was calling a demon to hurt them, killing him was justified. And again, it's not about whether the fighter could have known with certainty what the spell was, but whether a little paranoia could have made the guess. In any jurisdiction that recognizes magic, casting a spell on an unwilling target would be battery. It's a little more complex, since he didn't own the item, but that could make this robbery which is 25 to life in California, not counting any aggravating factors of using mind-controlling magic (which would be at least equal to that of using a gun.) So what? It doesn't make him a metagamer, nor does it mean that what was done to him was fair. [/QUOTE]

Verification