Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="GreyLord" data-source="post: 7883101" data-attributes="member: 4348">Hmm, if I had the ability to go and change some things...I'd do away with some of the more controversial decisions of the second film.First, no killing Luke...period...at least in that film.  He stays alive.Second, Luke is there akin more along with what JJ Abrahms seemed to have wanted Luke to have been doing in the 3rd film.  Luke HAD been searching for the Jedi Temple and the Wayfinders.  He had gotten stuck there or something. He would have trained Rey more (so longer training montage...etc) and the chase of TLJ is NOT a mere 18 hours.  It would be at least fuel enough for a week or two. TLJ would have taken place at least a couple months (let's give it 3-6 months) after the end of The Force awakens.Rey would not have been a Palpatine.  She would have been either Luke's daughter or the daughter of Kylo Ren.Luke would have probably died in the third movie in some way, possibly be the one who dies at the Death Star Lightsaber fight instead by letting Kylo Ren strike him down as Leia talks to him...OR...even better...have Rey be the one who strikes him down as she is confused by the Dark side with Kylo watching who then turns as he has lost his chance for vengeance.  He hears his mother, gets turned by his father's memory, and turns to the Light, while Rey, having killed Luke goes off to Ach-Too and we see it just as we see the scene currently between her and Jedi ghost Luke (for the most part at least).At the end of the movie, no health resurrection.  Rey doesn't come back to life by a Kiss.  It could be that Anakin stands there between her and Palpatine as a ghost and absorbs the lightning helping her reflect it back, and Kylo makes a sacrifice to save her, but no Force Resurrections.  Palpatine himself is a Force Sith Spirit held by a Sith Holocron or something in that spot rather than a zombie attempting to come back.And that's bout it.  I think that covers most more controversial portions by small changes in the movie itself.Since these are only small changes, I think that's about it.  I think we could have kept the Palpatine thing.</blockquote>

Verification