Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Grishnak" data-source="post: 1047864" data-attributes="member: 11932">In a session a couple of weeks ago my group fought and defeated a bugbear taking it hostage for info gathering. Then we then went into a major moral discussion on what to do. I'll describe the group then what the outcome was and ask what you would have done in the same boat.The group are mainly good aligned with only 1 possible neautral char in there. There was 2 minotaurs 1 n/g and myself c/g, a half celestial n/g, cleric n/g , wizard l/g and an npc ranger with racial hatred for the bugbear possibly neautral. The ranger wanted it dead the wizard was dead against it as it was unarmed. I suggested an arena fight on fair terms and the bugbear chose who to fight, it wouldn't fight. In the end with a lot of discussion and a detect evil cast (Slight evil) getting nowhere the ranger went to kill it, I stopped the ranger and released the bugbear to run back to it's base and warn the creatures there. Now I've come across this situation before and had the same moral objections from different players. Now would you just say it's evil and kill it, release it as I did or something else?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Grishnak, post: 1047864, member: 11932"] In a session a couple of weeks ago my group fought and defeated a bugbear taking it hostage for info gathering. Then we then went into a major moral discussion on what to do. I'll describe the group then what the outcome was and ask what you would have done in the same boat. The group are mainly good aligned with only 1 possible neautral char in there. There was 2 minotaurs 1 n/g and myself c/g, a half celestial n/g, cleric n/g , wizard l/g and an npc ranger with racial hatred for the bugbear possibly neautral. The ranger wanted it dead the wizard was dead against it as it was unarmed. I suggested an arena fight on fair terms and the bugbear chose who to fight, it wouldn't fight. In the end with a lot of discussion and a detect evil cast (Slight evil) getting nowhere the ranger went to kill it, I stopped the ranger and released the bugbear to run back to it's base and warn the creatures there. Now I've come across this situation before and had the same moral objections from different players. Now would you just say it's evil and kill it, release it as I did or something else? [/QUOTE]

Verification