Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Celebrim" data-source="post: 4229563" data-attributes="member: 4937">a) I don't think you can take a willingness to rebel as proof in and of itself of a non-lawful identity.  America's most famous rebel, Robert E. Lee, is an example of a lawful minded individual who is forced to rebel because of his allegiances ultimately bring him into conflict with lawful authority - which proves not to hold his highest allegiance.  It's not that you are loyal to lawful authority which determines whether you are lawful, but whether you are loyal to an externally recognized code.b) Captain America's alignment has evolved over the years in responce to his writers evolving attitude toward America itself.  He's also been portrayed in different ways in different alternate universes.  c) Ok, despite all that, I grant you that Cap' is NG in most incarnations.</blockquote>