Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ProfessorCirno" data-source="post: 4232461" data-attributes="member: 65637">Alright, let's say it is guerrilla warfare.But are you now going to say sniping out government officials is lawful?  And in other versions, he's just a bandit who also attacks the prince, who makes no differentials between stealing from the rich or the poor.  So for your version where he is a knight errant in the woods, there's a version where he is just a bandit.Why, because it changes?  Don't be rediculous.Who says he starts LG or ends LG?  It's very possible he starts and ends NG, not LG.People do actions contrary to their "moral compass" all the time, MOST often without realizing it.So what tracks alignment if it's not actions?  Your entire argument seems set up around "Evil people can NEVER DO GOOD THINGS, NEVER, NEIN, CANNOT HAPPEN."Why is it silliness?  It happened in the real world.So you don't think anyone in the French Resistance fought against Nazis simply for the sake of wanting to fight against someone?  Gee, that sounds completely contradictory to what you said earlier....Ok?  And?It didn't become that until MANY years later.  At the time, it was a bunch of uppity hicks from a backwater country rebelling against the most generous and kind government in Europe.  I always think of myself as more neutral ;pBut I very specifically pointed out the Sons of Liberty who, yes, were terrorists.  You didn't answer that point.</blockquote>