Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Moff_Tarkin" data-source="post: 4839602" data-attributes="member: 14175">Let me pose a question to all the people who still think its metagaming. When we first got the hunch the body was fake, how do you think we arrived at that conclusion? The entire metagaming argument only has one wobbly leg to stand on, the fact that we knew that a Will save had been made. But at the point where we said the corpse was fake, there had been no Will save.No one has argued the case for metagaming without bringing up the fact that we knew out of character that we had made Will saves. So if we concluded the corpse was a fake before any Will save was called for, it invalidates the entire argument.Lets pause the game right after we said the corpse was fake and right before the Will save was called for. At this exact junction in time, us metagaming is “IMPOSSIBLE”. We knew nothing about this module, and had no indication of any kind that the corpse was an illusion. We, as players, had no knowledge whatsoever. So where does this “out of character knowledge” come from? Are people honestly trying to argue that we used knowledge we didn’t have. Wow, we must be psychic or something.</blockquote>