Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Greenfield" data-source="post: 5967090" data-attributes="member: 6669384">As I said, you can rationalize your way around this pretty easily.&nbsp; The question I raised was whether or not you want to.(By the way, most spells that affect a creature treat their attended items as part of the creature.&nbsp; That is, Flesh to Stone petrifies the person and their gear.&nbsp; Enlarge Person does the same, as do a lot of other non-damaging spells.&nbsp; So there's already a rules-based explanation for the argument you're trying to raise.As for a field of grass or a stretch of sand?&nbsp; There are Illusion spelles specific to this, such as Hallucinatory Terrain.&nbsp; Other illusions aren't supposed to go there.But like I said, you can rationalize a way around a lot of rules.&nbsp; This is just another one.&nbsp;That being said, if someone attacks one of the &quot;mannequins&quot; in your illusory collective, have it fall down, wounded or killed, in a realistic fashion.&nbsp; That is, have it react appropriately to the event, and the illusion as a whole can be maintained.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Greenfield, post: 5967090, member: 6669384"] As I said, you can rationalize your way around this pretty easily. The question I raised was whether or not you want to. (By the way, most spells that affect a creature treat their attended items as part of the creature. That is, [I]Flesh to Stone[/I] petrifies the person and their gear. [I]Enlarge Person[/I] does the same, as do a lot of other non-damaging spells. So there's already a rules-based explanation for the argument you're trying to raise. As for a field of grass or a stretch of sand? There are Illusion spelles specific to this, such as [I]Hallucinatory Terrain.[/I] Other illusions aren't supposed to go there. But like I said, you can rationalize a way around a lot of rules. This is just another one. That being said, if someone attacks one of the "mannequins" in your illusory collective, have it fall down, wounded or killed, in a realistic fashion. That is, have it react appropriately to the event, and the illusion as a whole can be maintained. [/QUOTE]

Verification