Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Seeten" data-source="post: 2885648" data-attributes="member: 27186">So your contention, then, is that &quot;Claws of the Beast&quot; are a psionic weapon, and not a natural weapon?Thats easy to hash out, depending on whether or not you can use them as a secondary attack, while using a weapon primary.Lets check the SRD. =)Looks to me like them claws are natural weapons. It states it twice, in 2 seperate paragraphs.Or, your contention is you must take the feat once, and it only affects one single claw. In this case, I'd want our Dire Tiger to submit to telling us which of his paws has the 1 claw he has improved, because the other 3 are normal. And then, I sunder it, destroying his feat choice. Even if he has regeneration, when it regrows, it wont be &quot;this claw&quot;.I think that sounds pretty silly. I would be much more likely to say common sense states that &quot;This natural weapon&quot; means &quot;Claw&quot; because thats what you took. Claw with a graft, claw of the beast, claw of the vampire, claw of granny mcphee, all are This natural weapon, &quot;claw&quot;.I think Hypersmurf hit the nail on the head when he compared it to WF: Bastard Sword. It doesnt mean the single solitary bastard sword in your hand, it means any bastard sword.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Seeten, post: 2885648, member: 27186"] So your contention, then, is that "Claws of the Beast" are a psionic weapon, and not a natural weapon? Thats easy to hash out, depending on whether or not you can use them as a secondary attack, while using a weapon primary. Lets check the SRD. =) Looks to me like them claws are natural weapons. It states it twice, in 2 seperate paragraphs. Or, your contention is you must take the feat once, and it only affects one single claw. In this case, I'd want our Dire Tiger to submit to telling us which of his paws has the 1 claw he has improved, because the other 3 are normal. And then, I sunder it, destroying his feat choice. Even if he has regeneration, when it regrows, it wont be "this claw". I think that sounds pretty silly. I would be much more likely to say common sense states that "This natural weapon" means "Claw" because thats what you took. Claw with a graft, claw of the beast, claw of the vampire, claw of granny mcphee, all are This natural weapon, "claw". I think Hypersmurf hit the nail on the head when he compared it to WF: Bastard Sword. It doesnt mean the single solitary bastard sword in your hand, it means any bastard sword. [/QUOTE]

Verification