Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="MarkChevallier" data-source="post: 5787122" data-attributes="member: 55538">But perfection is different for many people. Making it perfect for you may make it not good enough for someone else. Do you think, if you got to say exactly how 5E was, in every detail, to satisfy your personal tastes alone, it would keep the market? But it might be perfect for you.And both 3E and 4E are clearly good enough for lots of people! As were BECMI, 1E, 2E and all of them. In response to Crazy Jerome, I agree completely; when you can improve something in a way that most people will appreciate and won't turn too many people off, go ahead. That's great, and I'm not arguing against progress here. Just saying, there are many competing tastes in the D&D world, and you can't make the game perfect for all of them. You make it as good as you can while still being good enough for all of them.</blockquote>