Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="KarinsDad" data-source="post: 4945906" data-attributes="member: 2011">So, how exactly did I go from slot 7 Alternate #1 to below slot 8, not an Alternate at all because you missed one score? Sounds a little fishy mate.I personally think that you should have given the new guy a chance (as it suggests on the ENWorld sticky). Many of these people here are in multiple games already as you already know. If DMs only pick &quot;their favorite entries&quot; and &quot;people they play with in other games&quot;, then new people will never get into a game. You (and other DMs here on these boards) should strongly consider that as part of their selection process.I also think that once you made a selection, you shouldn't have gone back and changed it. You might consider that fair, but sorry, it's not. It reeks of favoritism (especially since Sparky is potentially your DM in another game) and was totally unfair to announce a cut and then kick someone off that list.Uncool dude.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="KarinsDad, post: 4945906, member: 2011"] So, how exactly did I go from slot 7 Alternate #1 to below slot 8, not an Alternate at all because you missed [b]one[/b] score? Sounds a little fishy mate. I personally think that you should have given the new guy a chance (as it suggests on the ENWorld sticky). Many of these people here are in multiple games already as you already know. If DMs only pick "their favorite entries" and "people they play with in other games", then new people will never get into a game. You (and other DMs here on these boards) should strongly consider that as part of their selection process. I also think that once you made a selection, you shouldn't have gone back and changed it. You might consider that fair, but sorry, it's not. It reeks of favoritism (especially since Sparky is potentially your DM in another game) and was totally unfair to announce a cut and then kick someone off that list. Uncool dude. [/QUOTE]

Verification