Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="KarinsDad" data-source="post: 4946030" data-attributes="member: 2011">I don't have a bad attitude. You just got the BS flag thrown at you and you don't like it.You put me as first alternate and even though I didn't make the cut, I didn't say a word. I could have not made the alternate cut either and I still wouldn't have said a word (unlike KS and Sparky who did whine right away). Everyone who does not make the cut is disappointed. That's life.I personally thought renau1g's super optimized Orb Wizard with a M/C of Cleric and a background practically out of PHB II pretty darn unoriginal and typically min/maxed, but I didn't say a word. Have fun when he locks down the Elite or Solo most of the time and your BBEG is just sitting there.Orb Wizards with a M/C of Cleric are a dime a dozen. Every min/maxer wants to play one of those. Tomb Wizards with a M/C of Shaman are unique. So although I thought your selection system was sub-par, I didn't say a word.I wasn't crying sour grapes. You're DM. Your choice.It was when you brought two players up in the list and kicked two players down, that's when I called BS.You consider that fair? Whatever dude.I had no problem with your selection process until you started monkeying with it. If you made a scoring mistake, you should have just sucked it up and not told anyone.Learn from your mistakes and stand by your rulings. You'll piss fewer people off. And grow a thicker skin while you're at it.Personally, I think you owe Vertexx99 a major apology. You screwed him over royally.Have fun with your game.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="KarinsDad, post: 4946030, member: 2011"] I don't have a bad attitude. You just got the BS flag thrown at you and you don't like it. You put me as first alternate and even though I didn't make the cut, I didn't say a word. I could have not made the alternate cut either and I still wouldn't have said a word (unlike KS and Sparky who did whine right away). Everyone who does not make the cut is disappointed. That's life. I personally thought renau1g's super optimized Orb Wizard with a M/C of Cleric and a background practically out of PHB II pretty darn unoriginal and typically min/maxed, but I didn't say a word. Have fun when he locks down the Elite or Solo most of the time and your BBEG is just sitting there. Orb Wizards with a M/C of Cleric are a dime a dozen. Every min/maxer wants to play one of those. Tomb Wizards with a M/C of Shaman are unique. So although I thought your selection system was sub-par, I didn't say a word. I wasn't crying sour grapes. You're DM. Your choice. It was when you brought two players up in the list and kicked two players down, that's when I called BS. You consider that fair? Whatever dude. I had no problem with your selection process until you started monkeying with it. If you made a scoring mistake, you should have just sucked it up and not told anyone. Learn from your mistakes and stand by your rulings. You'll piss fewer people off. And grow a thicker skin while you're at it. Personally, I think you owe Vertexx99 a major apology. You screwed him over royally. Have fun with your game. [/QUOTE]

Verification