Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Bedrockgames" data-source="post: 7558088" data-attributes="member: 85555"><p>Pemerton you are attributing positions to me that I don't hold and statements to my posts I never made. I never assumed the only possibilities were players narrating or GM adjudicating. And I know perfectly well about Just say yes (I mentioned it in one of my earlier posts). And my final quote you completely misunderstand. I never was suggesting the GM decides what happens when players attack orcs. All I was asking in this post was what you definition of mother may I is and where you disagree with me. Instead I got another round of debate over each paragraph in the question. That post was in response to your's where it became clear we might have a misunderstanding. Because I thought you were defining mother may I as a particular thing, and you seemed to be saying you were not. You keep quibbling with my use of words like judgement. I don't seem to be having trouble communicating with other posters using the language I use. I feel like you are deliberately taking a fine tooth comb to my words and reading them as uncharitably as possible. Either way, this post was just a request for clarification on mother may I not an invitation for more grilling on terms.</p></blockquote><p></p>

[QUOTE="Bedrockgames, post: 7558088, member: 85555"] Pemerton you are attributing positions to me that I don't hold and statements to my posts I never made. I never assumed the only possibilities were players narrating or GM adjudicating. And I know perfectly well about Just say yes (I mentioned it in one of my earlier posts). And my final quote you completely misunderstand. I never was suggesting the GM decides what happens when players attack orcs. All I was asking in this post was what you definition of mother may I is and where you disagree with me. Instead I got another round of debate over each paragraph in the question. That post was in response to your's where it became clear we might have a misunderstanding. Because I thought you were defining mother may I as a particular thing, and you seemed to be saying you were not. You keep quibbling with my use of words like judgement. I don't seem to be having trouble communicating with other posters using the language I use. I feel like you are deliberately taking a fine tooth comb to my words and reading them as uncharitably as possible. Either way, this post was just a request for clarification on mother may I not an invitation for more grilling on terms. [/QUOTE]

Verification