Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Amphytrion" data-source="post: 9806590" data-attributes="member: 7046181">I think that the answer is split, at least on my case. The following is exclusively from a DM perspective.I am a big fan of Chris Perkins and most of the material he worked on directly fo 5e. All of the most iconic and most inspiring 5e modules are his (Curse of Strahd, Tomb of Anhilation, Waterdeep: Dragon Heist, etc.), and you can tell, because he had an eye for setting, drama and humor that is not well matched by his successors. After his last major adventure, Wild Beyond the Witchlight, none of the WotC modules have successfully emulated Perkins's writing style. In fact, all post-Perkins modules have major problems to differing degrees, and sometimes are just wrongheaded (Dragonlance: Shadow of the Dragon Queen, Phandelver and Below). That being said, Perkins had already stepped away from adventure writing for a few years, so I'm not sure his departure impacts that front too much.What Chris Perkins's departure really does impact is the institutional knowledge of WotC: he was lorekeeper, experienced adventure writer, storyteller, D&D guru, and elder statesman all at once, and I think WotC is poorer for not having one of these roles (let alone all).As for Jeremy Crawford, I think that, in general, his impulses are completely contrary to my whole DMing philosophy. Most major reestructurings that took place in the game from 2020 onwards (when he took over for Mike Mearls) have been for the worse. This includes a swath of new changes in the 2024 edition that generally seem to me completely misguided (e.g. hiding is now a set DC, instead of a contested check; same with influencing). I also think Crawford was actively averse to offering storytelling support for DMs (or unsure of how to do so), and we have gotten a very player-focused slew of releases instead. Adventures, settings, DM tools, all worsened during his tenure (compare Vecna to Strahd, or Planescape to Wildemount/Eberron). There are exceptions, but they're mostly James Wyatt's books (who is wonderful on his own and has been carefully iterating on DM toolboxes for decades).I have nothing personally against Jeremy Crawford: in fact, in interviews, he seems like a lovely man. But purely from a DM-perspective, I think his 5-year stewardship (~2020-2025) of the game was overall much worse than the previous 5-years (~2014-2020). I am glad that there is new blood at the helm now (and glad James Wyatt stuck around to help them).</blockquote>

Verification