Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Akaiku" data-source="post: 4819155" data-attributes="member: 82224">And also:Was one pc worse off as a percentage of their max hp then the other? It's extremely gamest to say that players have 3 states of health: Fine, Bloodied and Dieing/dead. Telling your cleric that she can never tell which bloodied person is worse off is saying she went to healer school all that time and never took the primer of battlefield awareness.The point was, no. There is no rule that says you know exactly the hp and stuff of anyone you look at. (I think there is a power that does that on foes and such, as an aside) Not being able to see such subtile details is gamest though, and gamism encourages metagaming. Although, the default rules in DnD 4th ed is 'say yes'. Where does it say you don't know hp totals of allies? Or how many saves they have failed? What about what conditions currently are affecting them, as without that information, granting saves would be a guessing game as well?</blockquote>