Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Maxperson" data-source="post: 9156489" data-attributes="member: 23751">I'm not.  I've been seeing them ask for the same thing for years.  They spoke for themselves.Then you are arguing that beyond the core 3 books nothing should ever be made, because bloat.  So yes, you do need to prove your unsubstantiated claim. You've made a claim of fact without backing it up. That's poor arguing.No. Those were not bloat.  Some of it was poorly made and much of it was excellent, but poorly made does not equate to bloat, nor does it equate to happening because too much stuff has been released.3e was a bit too overbalanced for me.  Not enough to ruin the edition and it's still my favorite, but it could have used a bit of scaling back.  As for DM's guild, much if it is even worse.  What is good is usually only a few pages long and I'm simply not going to buy 30 books after having slogged through 300, when 1 book by WotC would be sufficient to give me the same stuff and almost surely be better balanced.</blockquote>