Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Enchanted Trinkets Complete--a hardcover book containing over 500 magic items for your D&D games!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Melan" data-source="post: 2983301" data-attributes="member: 1713">Here is some concrete evidence for the posts (#23, #25) I made yesterday regarding the merits of Keep on the Borderlands. All quotes are from the module.Dungeon Mastering Keep on the Borderlands (p 2.):p 3.The inn and the tavern (p 10.):Based on this evidence, it seems to me thata) the module explicitely recommends the DM to modify for his own needs (there are other quotes other than the one I supplied, but I didn’t type in those...);b) the module assumes the game will start with an exploration of the keep and that the tavern will have a crucial role;c) contrary to claims made here and in the Keep on the Borderlands thread, the inn is by no means a replacement for the tavern. It is a place to sleep in, but doesn’t offer anything else – for rumors, hiring and NPC encounters, the PCs have to visit the tavern.Also, the total description of the keep takes up six pages of text and two pages of maps (one of which is dedicated to the - IMHO mostly superfluous - map of the guild house in the keep. The wilderness and the dungeon take up 11.5 pages of text and three pages of maps (two on the inner cover, one inside the booklet). General and specific DMing info is cca. 5 pages. The remainig six are for charts, lists and other miscellaneous matter, for a total of 26 pages including the dungeon maps.The Village of Hommlet, another 24 page module, spends 1.5 pages on DMing notes, a whopping 9 pages on the village, two pages of village maps, three pages of village floor plans, leaving only four pages to the actual adventure and two pages to moathouse and dungeon maps. There are also three blank pages for some inexplicable reason. In the same space, B2 introduced a „whole microcosm, a world in miniature” (Gary’s words <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f609.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=";)" title="Wink    ;)"  data-smilie="2"data-shortname=";)" />) and them some!Of course, I don’t intend to say that there should be a formula determining how much space in a module should be dedicated to certain elements, or that calculating page count can provide us with valuable insights into adventure design. However, the proportions are certainly off here. [I have to say one good thing about T1: the cover of the mono version is one of the best TSR did, right there with the Otus Basic Set, the City of Brass DMG and Trampier’s idol cover PHB.]</blockquote>

Verification