Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Olaf the Stout" data-source="post: 4158039" data-attributes="member: 13703">It may have been a houserule, but I remember playing a 2E game that had a Thri-Kreen in the party with Multiattack (it could make attacks with multiple limbs).&nbsp; In that game if the Thri-Kreen rolled a 1 he lost the rest of his attacks for the round.&nbsp; I don't know if this was an official rule or one that our group made up though.As for our current 3.5E game, our rule is that if you roll a 1, make a confirmation roll (just like if you rolled a threat).&nbsp; If that confirmation roll would miss the AC of the opponent you are fighting then you have fumbled and your opponent gets an attack against you.I find that getting an attack against you is the closest opposite to a critical (which is basically equal to getting hit two or three times in one hit).&nbsp; Rolling to hit your opponent also makes the roll scale a bit better with your level, rather than just making a Dex check or something similar.Olaf the Stout</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Olaf the Stout, post: 4158039, member: 13703"] It may have been a houserule, but I remember playing a 2E game that had a Thri-Kreen in the party with Multiattack (it could make attacks with multiple limbs). In that game if the Thri-Kreen rolled a 1 he lost the rest of his attacks for the round. I don't know if this was an official rule or one that our group made up though. As for our current 3.5E game, our rule is that if you roll a 1, make a confirmation roll (just like if you rolled a threat). If that confirmation roll would miss the AC of the opponent you are fighting then you have fumbled and your opponent gets an attack against you. I find that getting an attack against you is the closest opposite to a critical (which is basically equal to getting hit two or three times in one hit). Rolling to hit your opponent also makes the roll scale a bit better with your level, rather than just making a Dex check or something similar. Olaf the Stout [/QUOTE]

Verification