Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="KarinsDad" data-source="post: 2256102" data-attributes="member: 2011">When you swing a weapon, you do not need to be in the opponent's space. Your weapon will be in the opponent's square and that is all you need in the Archmage shaping case.Gust of Wind will not work if there is no tunnel. The Line of Effect of Gust of Wind will be stopped by the Antimagic Field.Remember, we are talking about the ESA case here. The caster's square is still in the Antimagic Field, he is just not affected by it (as per the RAW of ESA).In the ESA case, your opponent is in an Antimagic Field and your Quickened Dispel Magic will not work on him, even if he is grappling you.Yes we are.You appear to be confusing/combining the Archmage shaping with the ESA shaping. They are two different effects with two different set of limitations.The Archmage case has entire 5 foot squares that are not affected by the spell.The ESA case only has the creature not affected by the spell.Because of this, you get different results in what is allowed and not allowed.</blockquote>