Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Burnside" data-source="post: 9850436" data-attributes="member: 6910340">IMO this is mostly a quite solid "do not buy" list, but I would argue in favor of a few on there.Dragonheist - very terrible, yesDungeon of the Mad Mage - I think this is well worth buying, but not to run the whole as a campaign. Most of the dungeon levels are very, very good and can be cannibalized. Most groups just don't need to run 23 dungeon levels. Kind of a brilliant book, though. Third parties have done color versions of the maps which really elevates the experience, especially for VTT play.Storm Kings Thunder - really badAcquisitions Incorporated - the adventure is quite good, but definitely not for all tastes. By no means a bad book.Shattered Obelisk - hugely disappointingThe Vecna One - The behavior and plan of the central villain is nonsense, which hurts it a lot and makes it hard to salvage. Has some good set pieces though.Strixhaven - BadDragonlance - This is pretty good tbhPlanescape - the adventure is one of the worst official WotC adventures of the 5E era. The setting book and bestiary are good though.Spelljammer - I actually really like the much-maligned Light of Xaryxis adventure. Setting book is disappointing, bestiary is ok. Kind of the mirror image of the Planescape box.Stanger Things boxed sets X2. - The first one is a gimmick, but not terrible or anything. The boxed set from last year is GREAT and anyone skipping it is missing out on 4 very solid tier one adventures and excellent production values.Descent into Avernus - pretty bad as written, yeah</blockquote>

Verification