Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Kobold Stew" data-source="post: 6216456" data-attributes="member: 23484">I don't claim to know all the rules to all editions, but I doubt there is anything definitive or not contradicted in some other place. What I do know is that when I play, what I hear is "I reach into my haversack and pull our the Spear of Doom" or whatever. It's a single action, accomplished in seconds, regardless of the total volume of the interdimensional storage space available. That game mechanical reason is the evidence I use to suggest that it's not a Newtonian space. Something happens that grants perfect search ability with a simple reach inside. Everything else is extrapolated from that.When you have played, have you ever voluntarily taken longer to dig out an object that you put into your bag of holding long before, and for narrative reasons have foregone acting because the item you wanted was at the bottom of the bag? That would, of course, be awesome -- but it is not something that I think is in any way usual. So -- no formal rules statement needed for me, and yes the idea is cool. Observations in play give me both mechanical and narrative reasons for it to be as described. Finally, I offered my perspective only as a suggestion, to help generate ideas for a cool campaign, not as an interpretation of a specific rule. Hope that helps!</blockquote>