Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="DEFCON 1" data-source="post: 9680256" data-attributes="member: 7006">If this is such a simple and elegant solution, then why did you bother coming here to make a thread just to tell us that your player was bummed about it?&nbsp; Cause that doesn't sound like the solution worked.&nbsp; Which means it wasn't simple and elegant at all.I mean if the point of the thread was just to let folks know about this particular rules quirk you found... you could have done that without the additional commentary about your player's feelings on the matter.&nbsp; But the fact you mentioned it has made most of us believe that you no longer have a simple and elegant solution, but rather an actual problem in your game you're looking for assistance to solve.&nbsp; And a lot of people are responding in regards to trying to help your player be less unhappy, not to bolster your decision on campaign rules.So I guess the big question is... what are you looking for here?&nbsp; Do you want people to give you the thumbs-up to you continuing to use this policy of yours even if the player is unhappy?&nbsp; Or do you want all of us to just forget about that part of your post where you talk about your player, and only talk about this particular Sentinel feat rules quirk?&nbsp; What do you want from the rest of us?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="DEFCON 1, post: 9680256, member: 7006"] If this is such a simple and elegant solution, then why did you bother coming here to make a thread just to tell us that your player was bummed about it? Cause that doesn't sound like the solution worked. Which means it wasn't simple and elegant at all. I mean if the point of the thread was just to let folks know about this particular rules quirk you found... you could have done that without the additional commentary about your player's feelings on the matter. But the fact you mentioned it has made most of us believe that you no longer have a simple and elegant solution, but rather an actual problem in your game you're looking for assistance to solve. And a lot of people are responding in regards to trying to help your player be less unhappy, not to bolster your decision on campaign rules. So I guess the big question is... what are you looking for here? Do you want people to give you the thumbs-up to you continuing to use this policy of yours even if the player is unhappy? Or do you want all of us to just forget about that part of your post where you talk about your player, and [I]only[/I] talk about this particular Sentinel feat rules quirk? What do you want from the rest of us? [/QUOTE]

Verification