Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Scion" data-source="post: 1752448" data-attributes="member: 5777">Just showing you what the game defines as a crit. We are in the rules forum after all.Check your own hypocrasy at the door. I was telling you that just because you feel crits are a certain way does not make it so. The definition for a crit is above, whatever you wish to assign it above and beyond that is your own business. But, a crit is different than a regular hit. The differences are in the quote I gave.When you have seen the math run a few dozen times over various boards and threads one tends not to redue the math everytime someone comes in and doesnt want to run a search.If a character is critting 30% of the time then likely that is how they built the character, with that in mind. Personally, I prefer to allow nonoverpowered builds while trying to keep out those that are without question overpowered.The numbers say differently. They win.Lets see.. skill + natural talent vs skill + weapons talent.Sounds like a pretty fair comparison to me. They are both plus's to hit, letting them stack is perfectly balanced. Which is very similar to improved crit and keen.If you wish to say it is unbalanced, and dont wish to search for threads that prove otherwise, feel free to go through the numbers.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Scion, post: 1752448, member: 5777"] Just showing you what the game defines as a crit. We are in the rules forum after all. Check your own hypocrasy at the door. I was telling you that just because you feel crits are a certain way does not make it so. The definition for a crit is above, whatever you wish to assign it above and beyond that is your own business. But, a crit is different than a regular hit. The differences are in the quote I gave. When you have seen the math run a few dozen times over various boards and threads one tends not to redue the math everytime someone comes in and doesnt want to run a search. If a character is critting 30% of the time then likely that is how they built the character, with that in mind. Personally, I prefer to allow nonoverpowered builds while trying to keep out those that are without question overpowered. The numbers say differently. They win. Lets see.. skill + natural talent vs skill + weapons talent. Sounds like a pretty fair comparison to me. They are both plus's to hit, letting them stack is perfectly balanced. Which is very similar to improved crit and keen. If you wish to say it is unbalanced, and dont wish to search for threads that prove otherwise, feel free to go through the numbers. [/QUOTE]

Verification