Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="JacktheRabbit" data-source="post: 812672" data-attributes="member: 525">No, that player was CHEATING and using meta-knowledge that his character had no way of knowing to try to use a spell that should work.If the character was 10th level and using a spell the exact same way in the exact same situation that he had before then he has every right to expect a certain result.The first time anything is done in a completely new to the character situation he should NEVER expect to know exactly what will happen. That is cheating pure and simple.If that still makes no sense look at it this way. Unless a Player uses META knowledge the Magic Weapon spell made no sense to use. Granting it to a barbarian that was already hitting with every blow and doing decent damage was a complete waste of a spell. What is a +1 hit and damage to a character doing +8 attack and 2D6+6 damage? Its trivial.&nbsp; But if that character uses meta knowledge and knows that the spell will negate the DR and allow all his damage to go through then he is pure and simple cheating.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="JacktheRabbit, post: 812672, member: 525"] No, that player was CHEATING and using meta-knowledge that his character had no way of knowing to try to use a spell that should work. If the character was 10th level and using a spell the exact same way in the exact same situation that he had before then he has every right to expect a certain result. The first time anything is done in a completely new to the character situation he should NEVER expect to know exactly what will happen. That is cheating pure and simple. If that still makes no sense look at it this way. Unless a Player uses META knowledge the Magic Weapon spell made no sense to use. Granting it to a barbarian that was already hitting with every blow and doing decent damage was a complete waste of a spell. What is a +1 hit and damage to a character doing +8 attack and 2D6+6 damage? Its trivial. But if that character uses meta knowledge and knows that the spell will negate the DR and allow all his damage to go through then he is pure and simple cheating. [/QUOTE]

Verification