Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Gizzard" data-source="post: 812706" data-attributes="member: 527">Although the 3rd Edition ruleset is more complete than 2E or 1E, its still the DMs job to keep things rolling by making up rules for situations that havent been covered.  In my experience, this means that the DM is making a good handful of judgement calls and new rules on the fly every session. The players have to "trust" the DM to do this fairly, or else they cant play an average session without running into conflict.  As for Docs particular situation, the DM has to respond clearly to the player to make sure he understands that you havent forgotten about the magic weapon rule, but other than that I dont think you have any obligation to spell out the minutia of the new DR rules.  When this comes up, I do exactly what Dash suggested, "You are a bit surprised that your beloved magic weapon has let you down in this case."</blockquote>