Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sunseeker" data-source="post: 5911614">Hard caps limit the high-level wizard, but don't do anything to lift up the lower level one.Woah, logic FAIL.&nbsp; First off, we all know there's going to be a &quot;core&quot; to 5e, which ideally will be rather unique in it's own right and not simply a retroclone of some given edition's first few books.&nbsp; Any modularity will be to swing the game more in one direction of another, but no matter which way things go, they will be built upon 4e's CORE, which will likely be some form of compromise and learning from multiple editions.Second, 5e's goal is not to replicate 1e's play.&nbsp; 5e's goal is to provide the ability to play in a style similar to older editions.&nbsp; Style of play and play replication are two totally different goals.&nbsp; Feeling like you're playing in a 1e game is greatThird, there are so many players who want so many things, anyone who attempts to claim they &quot;know what players want&quot; is flat out BSing, so I call shenanigans.&nbsp; Players want good material.&nbsp; If they want a retroclone, there's plenty of those out there.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sunseeker, post: 5911614"] Hard caps limit the high-level wizard, but don't do anything to lift up the lower level one. Woah, logic FAIL. First off, we all know there's going to be a "core" to 5e, which ideally will be rather unique in it's own right and not simply a retroclone of some given edition's first few books. Any modularity will be to swing the game more in one direction of another, but no matter which way things go, they will be built upon 4e's CORE, which will likely be some form of compromise and learning from multiple editions. Second, 5e's goal is not to replicate 1e's play. 5e's goal is to provide the ability to play in a style similar to older editions. Style of play and play replication are two totally different goals. [I]Feeling[/I] like you're playing in a 1e game is great Third, there are so many players who want so many things, anyone who attempts to claim they "know what players want" is flat out BSing, so I call shenanigans. Players want good material. If they want a retroclone, there's plenty of those out there. [/QUOTE]

Verification