Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Herschel" data-source="post: 5914292" data-attributes="member: 78357">LoL, get some context. 3E was a better designed game than 2E, which was better designed than 1E and 4E was better designed than 3E. That's just objective fact because every edition thus far has learned from and mechanically improved upon things of the past. It's evolution. OD&amp;D was the first and had the most holes because, well, it was first. There was really nothing to expand upon but the original idea.&nbsp;AD&amp;D took that game, added to it and expanded upon it.&nbsp;2E did the same and fixed/codified a few things from 1E.&nbsp;3E, more of the same.&nbsp;4E, ditto. &nbsp;That's not to say everyone will prefer any particular edition. As I said I prefer 2E to 3E even though 3E is a better designed game. &nbsp;I also prefer older video games and hate Halo/God of War/etc. even though the latter are better designed games. I'd rather play Frogger. &nbsp;There are also better ways of cooking, but making an old barrel in to a smoker is still awesome for brisket and ribs. &nbsp;Classic sports cars handle like crap and ride like a buckboard but a late 60's Mustang is still cool as heck.&nbsp;Just a few examples.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Herschel, post: 5914292, member: 78357"] LoL, get some context. 3E was a better designed game than 2E, which was better designed than 1E and 4E was better designed than 3E. That's just objective fact because every edition thus far has learned from and mechanically improved upon things of the past. It's evolution. OD&D was the first and had the most holes because, well, it was first. There was really nothing to expand upon but the original idea. AD&D took that game, added to it and expanded upon it. 2E did the same and fixed/codified a few things from 1E. 3E, more of the same. 4E, ditto. That's not to say everyone will prefer any particular edition. As I said I prefer 2E to 3E even though 3E is a better designed game. I also prefer older video games and hate Halo/God of War/etc. even though the latter are better designed games. I'd rather play Frogger. There are also better ways of cooking, but making an old barrel in to a smoker is still awesome for brisket and ribs. Classic sports cars handle like crap and ride like a buckboard but a late 60's Mustang is still cool as heck. Just a few examples. [/QUOTE]

Verification