Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="stonegod" data-source="post: 5392103" data-attributes="member: 36973">Judges: Need ClarificationJudges: Please Clarify Retirement RulesSo, Fissure died in an horrible near-TPK in a fluffy game.I decided to &quot;retool&quot; Fissure into Fracture, a revenant version of Fissure &quot;come-back wrong&quot; using the retirement rules.I created Fracture using Fissure's XP. Option A of the retirement rules say &quot;Create the new character at the same level as the old character&quot; while Option B is the &quot;create one at a lower level, but gain XP to bank for other character.&quot; So, I wrote down Fissure's XP for Fracture.I have been told by a non-Judge reviewer that this was incorrect, and that 970 XP Fissure earned above the 3rd level mark is wasted (as Option A has no &quot;unused XP rewarded back to you&quot; option). I see both potential readings in what is in the charter.If loosing XP w/o compensation is the case, I need to know so I can pull Fracture out of r1's game until this issue is resolved (either through DM points [which will waste 1 as he only needs 1.06 of one] or proposal).Thanks.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="stonegod, post: 5392103, member: 36973"] [b]Judges: Need Clarification[/b] [b]Judges: Please Clarify Retirement Rules[/b] So, Fissure died in an horrible near-TPK in a fluffy game. I decided to "retool" Fissure into Fracture, a revenant version of Fissure "come-back wrong" using the retirement rules. I created Fracture using Fissure's XP. Option A of the retirement rules say "Create the new character at the same level as the old character" while Option B is the "create one at a lower level, but gain XP to bank for other character." So, I wrote down Fissure's XP for Fracture. I have been told by a non-Judge reviewer that this was incorrect, and that 970 XP Fissure earned above the 3rd level mark is wasted (as Option A has no "unused XP rewarded back to you" option). I see both potential readings in what is in the charter. If loosing XP w/o compensation is the case, I need to know so I can pull Fracture out of r1's game until this issue is resolved (either through DM points [which will waste 1 as he only needs 1.06 of one] or proposal). Thanks. [/QUOTE]

Verification