Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Argyle King" data-source="post: 6161780" data-attributes="member: 58416">In theory, I like the idea.I'm waiting to see how the implementation works out in actual play.edit:&nbsp; I'm not huge on the idea of advantage so much, but I'd like to see how the idea is expanded in future supplements**.&nbsp; At the risk of causing some flames, I do believe D&amp;D has started to be viewed as something other than a roleplaying game.&nbsp; I'm not denying that rping happens; in my own group, it happens rather frequently.&nbsp; However, I've also noticed that the mentality behind the group I game with seems to be different (even without discussing it) when we play D&amp;D when compared to some of the other games.&nbsp; I can't speak on behalf of anyone else or other groups; just my own isolated experience here and the handful of times I've played with other groups.&nbsp; That's not in any way meant to demean D&amp;D; I'm simply recounting my experience, and my experience is that most of the D&amp;D groups I've played with tend to approach the game differently (without even discussing it) than they approach other games.&nbsp; **Though this brings up a question I had in a different thread in which I mused over how long it would be until 5th Edition would resemble the kind of game I want to play.&nbsp; That's beyond the scope of this particular thread though.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Argyle King, post: 6161780, member: 58416"] In theory, I like the idea. I'm waiting to see how the implementation works out in actual play. edit: I'm not huge on the idea of advantage so much, but I'd like to see how the idea is expanded in future supplements**. At the risk of causing some flames, I do believe D&D has started to be viewed as something other than a roleplaying game. I'm not denying that rping happens; in my own group, it happens rather frequently. However, I've also noticed that the mentality behind the group I game with seems to be different (even without discussing it) when we play D&D when compared to some of the other games. I can't speak on behalf of anyone else or other groups; just my own isolated experience here and the handful of times I've played with other groups. That's not in any way meant to demean D&D; I'm simply recounting my experience, and my experience is that most of the D&D groups I've played with tend to approach the game differently (without even discussing it) than they approach other games. **Though this brings up a question I had in a different thread in which I mused over how long it would be until 5th Edition would resemble the kind of game I want to play. That's beyond the scope of this particular thread though. [/QUOTE]

Verification