Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Wombat" data-source="post: 1276657" data-attributes="member: 8447">Okay, I've taken a bit of flak here, and took no offense, but I feel I must answer here.I own the book.&nbsp; I have read through it.&nbsp; I discussed it with several of my players.&nbsp; I have gamed since 1976, so I feel I have a bit of a heritage regarding gaming in general and I know what my tastes are.&nbsp; I do not, now or ever, label the book &quot;crap&quot; -- I say it is not to my tastes and that is that.No, I have not played the game, but then again, I feel that I can judge a game is like based on reading through the rules and flavour material.Opinions were asked for here, and I thought I gave a fairly cogent set of objections.&nbsp; Is the game badly written?&nbsp; No.&nbsp; Is this a game that should be avoided at all costs?&nbsp; No.&nbsp; Is this a game for everyone?&nbsp; No.I have my opinion; you have yours.&nbsp; That is fine.&nbsp; I know that I am in a minority position on a lot of topics -- again, I take very little offense there.&nbsp; I did take offense here, and I am sorry that it came to that.This is all I shall say on the topic.For those of you who enjoy the game, as always, I hope that you continue to find an excellent gaming experience.&nbsp; While this is not the game for me, I know it is the game for others.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Wombat, post: 1276657, member: 8447"] Okay, I've taken a bit of flak here, and took no offense, but I feel I must answer here. I own the book. I have read through it. I discussed it with several of my players. I have gamed since 1976, so I feel I have a bit of a heritage regarding gaming in general and I know what my tastes are. I do not, now or ever, label the book "crap" -- I say it is not to my tastes and that is that. No, I have not played the game, but then again, I feel that I can judge a game is like based on reading through the rules and flavour material. Opinions were asked for here, and I thought I gave a fairly cogent set of objections. Is the game badly written? No. Is this a game that should be avoided at all costs? No. Is this a game for everyone? No. I have my opinion; you have yours. That is fine. I know that I am in a minority position on a lot of topics -- again, I take very little offense there. I did take offense here, and I am sorry that it came to that. This is all I shall say on the topic. For those of you who enjoy the game, as always, I hope that you continue to find an excellent gaming experience. While this is not the game for me, I know it is the game for others. [/QUOTE]

Verification