Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="jlhorner1974" data-source="post: 4493343" data-attributes="member: 8628">As originally presented, +2 prof. and d6/d6 damage, with no properties other than the standard Double ones (Defensive and OffHand), it seems kind of weak for a superior double 2H weapon.&nbsp; It's much weaker than any of the four double weapons in Adventurer's Vault (see the Double sword for closest comparison).&nbsp; Even if you bump the damage up to d8/d8 (which I think you should), it still comes out weaker than its breathren.I'm not sure what your could do to beef it up.Making it +2 d8/d8 Defensive OffHand with HighCrit or Brutal 1 would not be much different mechanics-wise from the Double sword (the average damage bonus of HighCrit or Brutal1 is probably pretty close to an extra +1 proficiency bonus).&nbsp; Giving it Reach and the Polearm type is a cool and interesting idea too -- getting two attacks per round at reach (Tempest fighter or ranger) might be just a bit much, but probably not.&nbsp; A Ranger can already get a Greatbow and do two attacks at 1d12 each from range (or step close and use a freakin' Craghammer in each hand).&nbsp; With Reach not in effect most of the time when it's not your turn anymore, it isn't really that ridiculous.&nbsp; If that's too much for you, what if you give the weapon a property that lets the wielder switch from a double weapon to a 2H weapon as a minor action?&nbsp; In double mode, it gets OffHand and Defensive, but in 2H mode it loses those and gains the Polearm type and Reach.&nbsp; It's a little complex, but a nice little bit of flexibility.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="jlhorner1974, post: 4493343, member: 8628"] As originally presented, +2 prof. and d6/d6 damage, with no properties other than the standard Double ones (Defensive and OffHand), it seems kind of weak for a superior double 2H weapon. It's much weaker than any of the four double weapons in Adventurer's Vault (see the Double sword for closest comparison). Even if you bump the damage up to d8/d8 (which I think you should), it still comes out weaker than its breathren. I'm not sure what your could do to beef it up. Making it +2 d8/d8 Defensive OffHand with HighCrit or Brutal 1 would not be much different mechanics-wise from the Double sword (the average damage bonus of HighCrit or Brutal1 is probably pretty close to an extra +1 proficiency bonus). Giving it Reach and the Polearm type is a cool and interesting idea too -- getting two attacks per round at reach (Tempest fighter or ranger) might be just a bit much, but probably not. A Ranger can already get a Greatbow and do two attacks at 1d12 each from range (or step close and use a freakin' Craghammer in each hand). With Reach not in effect most of the time when it's not your turn anymore, it isn't really that ridiculous. If that's too much for you, what if you give the weapon a property that lets the wielder switch from a double weapon to a 2H weapon as a minor action? In double mode, it gets OffHand and Defensive, but in 2H mode it loses those and gains the Polearm type and Reach. It's a little complex, but a nice little bit of flexibility. [/QUOTE]

Verification