Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Steverooo" data-source="post: 1976092" data-attributes="member: 9410">And like I said before, both she and Jack can do whatever they feel they have to!&nbsp; She can not like guns, and still be expert with them... just like Faramir in The Lord of the Rings (book, not movie version).Kate shot the bank robbers to keep them from killing the manager.&nbsp; Even then, she wounded them.&nbsp; If she'd a'wanted'em dead, they would've been.&nbsp; She wanted them disabled.&nbsp; And they were...Now back to the original question: Were the guns hers, or the &quot;Marshalls&quot;?&nbsp; She said they were his.&nbsp; She says she doesn't like guns (expertise notwithstanding).&nbsp; If they had been HER guns, I think she would have wanted them, and would have found a way to acquire them, no matter what... just like she did with the airplane.The fact is, she didn't care what Jack did with them.&nbsp; They were of absolutely no interest, to her.&nbsp; Ergo, they're not hers.As for her combat expertise, I have no doubt she could handle anyone on the island (Sayid included) bare-handed.&nbsp; Look at the way she disarmed Sawyer, after he shot the bear.&nbsp; I think she could kill anyone (except maybe Locke) with a broken shovel (even if she had to take it away from them, first).&nbsp; I also don't think she would want to...She doesn't like violence...&nbsp; Doesn't mean she isn't any good at it!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Steverooo, post: 1976092, member: 9410"] And like I said before, both she and Jack can do whatever they feel they [I]have[/I] to! She can not like guns, and still be expert with them... just like Faramir in [U]The Lord of the Rings[/U] (book, not movie version). Kate shot the bank robbers to keep them from killing the manager. Even then, she [I]wounded[/I] them. If she'd a'wanted'em dead, they would've been. She wanted them disabled. And they [I]were[/I]... Now back to the original question: Were the guns hers, or the "Marshalls"? She said they were his. She says she doesn't like guns (expertise notwithstanding). If they had been HER guns, I think she would have wanted them, and would have found a way to acquire them, no matter what... just like she did with the airplane. The fact is, she didn't care what Jack did with them. They were of absolutely no interest, to her. Ergo, they're not hers. As for her combat expertise, I have no doubt she could handle anyone on the island (Sayid included) bare-handed. Look at the way she disarmed Sawyer, after he shot the bear. I think she could kill anyone (except maybe Locke) with a broken shovel (even if she had to take it away from them, first). I also don't think she would want to... She doesn't like violence... Doesn't mean she isn't any good at it! [/QUOTE]

Verification