Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Taelorn76" data-source="post: 3544915" data-attributes="member: 14747">Desmond has mentioned before that he does not see a complete picture of the future only pieces of it. I don't thing Penny was every going to land on the island. He assumed it was her because he saw someone parachute down, found a bag with a book and a picture of him and Penny, none of his visions actually showed Penny as the parachuter. He assumed it was her.Same thing can be said about Charlie. In his visions I don't think Desmond was in the looking glass with Charlie. He saw Charlie stopping the jamming signalThe looking glass floodingClaire being rescuedHe may never have seen Charlie die like he did in the others. Struck by lighting, drowning, arrow through the throat, He may have assumed that Charlie had to died down there. And by telling Charlie that, Charlie felt that was the only option. But in reality, the signal was stopped and the rescue is on the way, and Charlie should've/could've been alive.</blockquote>