Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="The Grumpy Celt" data-source="post: 3495638" data-attributes="member: 1019">He’s not heavy. He my dad. Heh. I don’t think anyone will morn the passing of Anthony Cooper. And that plot line is nicely tied up. Jasper, Alabama, is also about 45-minutes from my parent’s house and is the closest place to them where you can by beer or liquor. As much of a plotter as Benry is, he’s not in control of everything – I don’t think he plotted or planned to have Richard give Locke the file on Ford. I don’t know where Locke got the tape and players, but I am skeptical of whether or not Benry was in control of that – having Benry be the perfect mastermind controlling everything would strip his character and the story of drama, in addition to seeming to smack of sad wish fulfillment on part of the writers.The discovery of a plane wreck at the bottom of a trench would be quite simple. The hoaxers would not even need to produce much in the way of material evidence. Presumably both the woman and Tony Tom heard about all of that through the news. Though Tony Tom was giving out a surprising amount of information.And again, everyone is keeping secretly for the sake of keeping secrets and playing sad and sorry little head games with everyone else.My mother is convinced they are all dead and in hell.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="The Grumpy Celt, post: 3495638, member: 1019"] He’s not heavy. He my dad. Heh. I don’t think anyone will morn the passing of Anthony Cooper. And that plot line is nicely tied up. Jasper, Alabama, is also about 45-minutes from my parent’s house and is the closest place to them where you can by beer or liquor. As much of a plotter as Benry is, he’s not in control of everything – I don’t think he plotted or planned to have Richard give Locke the file on Ford. I don’t know where Locke got the tape and players, but I am skeptical of whether or not Benry was in control of that – having Benry be the perfect mastermind controlling everything would strip his character and the story of drama, in addition to seeming to smack of sad wish fulfillment on part of the writers. The discovery of a plane wreck at the bottom of a trench would be quite simple. The hoaxers would not even need to produce much in the way of material evidence. Presumably both the woman and Tony Tom heard about all of that through the news. Though Tony Tom was giving out a surprising amount of information. And again, everyone is keeping secretly for the sake of keeping secrets and playing sad and sorry little head games with everyone else. My mother is convinced they are all dead and in hell. [/QUOTE]

Verification