Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Rel" data-source="post: 2728500" data-attributes="member: 99">Interesting episode for sure.&nbsp; I sat down to watch it just a minute or so after it started so I'm not sure about this, but did I see &quot;smoke monsters&quot; swarming over the wreckage of the crashed tail section?&nbsp; If so then it would support the possibility that the Others might have caused the crash in the first place or at least have been aware that it was happening so they could insert their infiltrators.One thing about Goodwin killing Nathan:&nbsp; It seems like a strategic error to have killed him rather than him being tortured by QBotU.&nbsp; If she cuts off his finger and he sticks to his story, I think that her reaction (and certainly that of the rest of the Tail Section) would be more akin to &quot;My God!&nbsp; What has my paranoia driven me to?!&quot; rather than &quot;Well I guess it must be somebody else.&quot;&nbsp; But this is probably my innate sense of tactics overiding what makes for a better story.(For the record, I bought into the Nathan=Other red herring because of the Canada thing too.)</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Rel, post: 2728500, member: 99"] Interesting episode for sure. I sat down to watch it just a minute or so after it started so I'm not sure about this, but did I see "smoke monsters" swarming over the wreckage of the crashed tail section? If so then it would support the possibility that the Others might have caused the crash in the first place or at least have been aware that it was happening so they could insert their infiltrators. One thing about Goodwin killing Nathan: It seems like a strategic error to have killed him rather than him being tortured by QBotU. If she cuts off his finger and he sticks to his story, I think that her reaction (and certainly that of the rest of the Tail Section) would be more akin to "My God! What has my paranoia driven me to?!" rather than "Well I guess it must be somebody else." But this is probably my innate sense of tactics overiding what makes for a better story. (For the record, I bought into the Nathan=Other red herring because of the Canada thing too.) [/QUOTE]

Verification