Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Aaron2" data-source="post: 389886" data-attributes="member: 1436">The Monsternomicon and MM2 are two different types of monster books. To be fair with a bad rating of the MM2, you'd have to give the Monsternomicon a bad rating because its lacks MM2's variety. The difference is one of format. You've chosen one format and declared it superior and then fault another book for not following that format. That's your prerogative, but don't come back and say &quot;I really hope people realize this&quot; when someone disagrees with you. I &quot;realize&quot; that I like both books, but I wouldn't like the MM2 if it were identical in format to the Monsternimicon.Monsternomicon is better than the MM2 at what it does: provide groovy steampunk monsters, while the MM2 is better than the Monsternomicon at what it does: provide a variety of high CR monsters and some conversions of old monsters.I don't see the CC2 as better than either of the others. Not even close.Aaron (realized what a pain it is to type &quot;Monsternomicon&quot; over and over)</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Aaron2, post: 389886, member: 1436"] The Monsternomicon and MM2 are two different types of monster books. To be fair with a bad rating of the MM2, you'd have to give the Monsternomicon a bad rating because its lacks MM2's variety. The difference is one of format. You've chosen one format and declared it superior and then fault another book for not following that format. That's your prerogative, but don't come back and say "I really hope people realize this" when someone disagrees with you. I "realize" that I like both books, but I wouldn't like the MM2 if it were identical in format to the Monsternimicon. Monsternomicon is better than the MM2 at what it does: provide groovy steampunk monsters, while the MM2 is better than the Monsternomicon at what it does: provide a variety of high CR monsters and some conversions of old monsters. I don't see the CC2 as better than either of the others. Not even close. Aaron (realized what a pain it is to type "Monsternomicon" over and over) [/QUOTE]

Verification