Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Holy Bovine" data-source="post: 390917" data-attributes="member: 203">Uh, there's only 4 entries/pages on the Carnival of Shadows in CC2.&nbsp; In CC there was a great deal more however (about 10(?) pages worth).I would challenge the notion that the Carnival of Shadows couldn't be put, rather easily into 'standard' fantasy campaign (ie European/Medieval times based).&nbsp; For things like a Dark Africa, Eastern/Asian setting I readily agree it would be more difficult (but certainly not impossible). I don't know anything about Steampunk and probably never will.As to the original poster - the review seem far too short in my opinion.&nbsp; I would have liked to see more details on the specifc things you didn't like and why.&nbsp; Even if you added 6 more monsters to praise/condemn the review would still have been a little short.&nbsp; More details on why some parts of the book worked and why (most) didn't.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Holy Bovine, post: 390917, member: 203"] Uh, there's only 4 entries/pages on the Carnival of Shadows in CC2. In CC there was a great deal more however (about 10(?) pages worth). I would challenge the notion that the Carnival of Shadows couldn't be put, rather easily into 'standard' fantasy campaign (ie European/Medieval times based). For things like a Dark Africa, Eastern/Asian setting I readily agree it would be more difficult (but certainly not impossible). I don't know anything about Steampunk and probably never will. As to the original poster - the review seem far too short in my opinion. I would have liked to see more details on the specifc things you didn't like and why. Even if you added 6 more monsters to praise/condemn the review would still have been a little short. More details on why some parts of the book worked and why (most) didn't. [/QUOTE]

Verification