Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="KarinsDad" data-source="post: 3155690" data-attributes="member: 2011">I don't buy this at all.The very nature of the spell is that one targets one of several indistinguishable targets per attack.Indistinguishable means that you cannot tell one from the other, not that you cannot tell that there are multiple ones and you cannot target multiple ones. That is not the definition of indistinguishable.If someone can learn which image is real from indistinguishable targets, he can also learn if one is fake.It also states to "generally" roll randomly. If an opponent already knows that an image is real or fake, there is no need to select that target again (depending on whether you want to hit an image or the real target).It also states that in order to "shuffle the deck" again (i.e. reconfound enemies who have learned the real caster), the caster has to move and merge his images. If the caster has not yet gotten a Move Action, he cannot do this.Are you claiming that if an enemy learns which image is real, that he must roll randomly even if he has this knowledge?If not, then why are you claiming that if an enemy learns that an image is fake, he must include that fake image in his random roll?</blockquote>