Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 2891091" data-attributes="member: 31734">I'm not dodging the question, I'm staying on the topic raised by the OP.1. If the target is in front of the wall, then the wall doesn't interfere.&nbsp; I assume therefore you mean behind the wall (with respective to the thrower).&nbsp; That actually has a different problem than what you ask about.&nbsp; Can you even throw the weapon at someone who has total cover?&nbsp; Not technically: &quot;You can’t make an attack against a target that has total cover.&quot;&nbsp; Therefore, you'd have to treat the attack as an attack on the wall, and the weapon flies through the air on its way back to the thrower.&nbsp; It never falls to the ground, however, in any circumstance.2. How far the weapon can travel to get back to the original position is not defined.&nbsp; That said, it's not explicitly limited, so I would have the axe keep moving until it found a way to its original position.&nbsp; Only in the case that it had no way out (forcecage for instance) would I say it could not make it back.&nbsp; But, even in that case, it may not fall to the ground.&nbsp; The thrower didn't catch it, but neither did the weapon fulfill its condition of returning for the &quot;falling to the ground clause&quot; to take effect.&nbsp; Despite that, I would still likely rule that it falls to the ground if the weapon cannot return.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Infiniti2000, post: 2891091, member: 31734"] I'm not dodging the question, I'm staying on the topic raised by the OP. 1. If the target is in front of the wall, then the wall doesn't interfere. I assume therefore you mean behind the wall (with respective to the thrower). That actually has a different problem than what you ask about. Can you even throw the weapon at someone who has total cover? Not technically: "You can’t make an attack against a target that has total cover." Therefore, you'd have to treat the attack as an attack on the wall, and the weapon flies through the air on its way back to the thrower. It never falls to the ground, however, in any circumstance. 2. How far the weapon can travel to get back to the original position is not defined. That said, it's not explicitly limited, so I would have the axe keep moving until it found a way to its original position. Only in the case that it had no way out (forcecage for instance) would I say it could not make it back. But, even in that case, it [I]may not[/I] fall to the ground. The thrower didn't catch it, but neither did the weapon fulfill its condition of returning for the "falling to the ground clause" to take effect. Despite that, I would still likely rule that it falls to the ground if the weapon cannot return. [/QUOTE]

Verification