Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="dave2008" data-source="post: 9115493" data-attributes="member: 83242">No, I was not talking about the MM3. I was talking about the <a href="https://www.dmsguild.com/product/158946/Dungeons--Dragons-Essentials-Monster-Vault-4e?language=de&filters=0_0_0_45349_0_0" target="_blank">Monster Vault</a> (and <a href="https://www.dmsguild.com/product/158948/Monster-Vault-Threats-to-the-Nentir-Vale-4e?term=threats+to+the+nentir+vale&filters=0_0_0_45349_0_0" target="_blank">MV: Threats to the Nentir Vale</a>)We had a slayer at our table and it worked well for us. I feel like we had an essentials druid or druid-like PC too, but I can't remember. We never had anyone play the classes you noted, so I can't speak to those.Whether or not the execution of a class was good, I appreciate they tried some different design space.  I think the game got better when everything wasn't AEDU.I don't disagree with this, but still not sure how it applies.I did not, it must have been someone else. I have talked about modularity before though.I find it unlikely too (as I pointed out with my next statement). I just saying it is possible.I didn't think we were arguing. I can believe one thing while also discussing different possibilities.I disagree. That was not the impression I had at the time and that is not the impression I got form the posts you quoted. What you quoted was WotC, fans, etc. and they pretty much all talked about "this edition." The over arching point was that 4e and essentials could both be used at the same time. One did not supersede the other. I none of those quotes, nor in my memory (which I admit could be wrong) did they think 4e/essentials would be a forever edition.I pretty much agree with all of this, except the bolded part.  I think people have been doubtful that 5e will be a forever edition from the beginning and still are. Many understand that this what WotC is selling, but I have seen many comments on this forum about how when sales start to sink we will see a new edition. The problem with 5e is that sales have not started to sink yet.</blockquote>

Verification