Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Altamont Ravenard" data-source="post: 1168235" data-attributes="member: 14700">OK, he're my little analysis. The Greatsword seems to come out on top by an insignificant amount...The 1st column represents the chance you have to hit. The 2nd column represents your chance of getting a critical hit. The 3rd column represents the chance of getting a normal hit (which is basically 1st column - 2nd column). The 4th column represents estimated damage output, ie (Chance to get a critical hit * average damage * 2) + (Chance to get a normal hit * average damage).For the greatsword, with Improved critical, you need to hit on a 17 (20%) or more to get a chance of getting a critical hit. Your chance of getting a critical hit is (Chance to hit)² if your to-hit probability (1st column) is &lt; 25%; and 20%*(Chance to hit) if your to-hit probability is &gt; 20%.For the falchion, with Improved critical, you need to hit on a 15 (30%) or more to get a chance of getting a critical hit. Your chance of getting a critical hit is (Chance to hit)² if your to-hit probability (1st column) is &lt; 35%; and 30%*(Chance to hit) if your to-hit probability is &gt; 30%.I hope the tables are ok...[code]Greatsword (crit 17-20, ave dam 7+2+10 = 19, ave crit dam 38)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; %ToHit&nbsp; &nbsp; %Crit&nbsp; &nbsp; %Normal&nbsp; &nbsp; Ave dam0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,005,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,3%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,8%&nbsp; &nbsp; 1,0010,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 1,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 2,0915,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 2,3%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,8%&nbsp; &nbsp; 3,2820,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 16,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,5625,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 5,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 20,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 5,7030,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 6,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 24,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 6,8435,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 7,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 28,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 7,9840,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 8,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 32,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,1245,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 36,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 10,2650,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 10,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 40,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 11,4055,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 11,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 44,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,5460,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 48,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 13,6865,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 13,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 52,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 14,8270,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 14,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 56,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 15,9675,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 15,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 60,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 17,1080,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 16,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 64,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 18,2485,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 17,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 68,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 19,3890,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 18,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 72,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 20,5295,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 19,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 76,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 21,66100,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 20,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 80,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 22,80Falchion (crit 15-20, ave dam 5+2+10 = 17, ave crit dam 34)&nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp; %ToHit&nbsp; &nbsp; %Crit&nbsp; &nbsp; %Normal&nbsp; &nbsp; Ave dam0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,005,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,3%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,8%&nbsp; &nbsp; 0,8910,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 1,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 1,8715,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 2,3%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,8%&nbsp; &nbsp; 2,9320,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 16,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 4,0825,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 6,3%&nbsp; &nbsp; 18,8%&nbsp; &nbsp; 5,3130,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 21,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 6,6335,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 10,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 24,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 7,7440,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 28,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 8,8445,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 13,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 31,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 9,9550,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 15,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 35,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 11,0555,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 16,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 38,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 12,1660,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 18,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 42,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 13,2665,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 19,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 45,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 14,3770,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 21,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 49,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 15,4775,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 22,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 52,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 16,5880,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 24,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 56,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 17,6885,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 25,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 59,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 18,7990,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 27,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 63,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 19,8995,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 28,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 66,5%&nbsp; &nbsp; 21,00100,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 30,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 70,0%&nbsp; &nbsp; 22,10[/code]Of course, any other input from other mathemagicians will be appreciated <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f642.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=":)" title="Smile&nbsp; &nbsp; :)"&nbsp; data-smilie="1"data-shortname=":)" />AR</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Altamont Ravenard, post: 1168235, member: 14700"] OK, he're my little analysis. The Greatsword seems to come out on top by an insignificant amount... The 1st column represents the chance you have to hit. The 2nd column represents your chance of getting a critical hit. The 3rd column represents the chance of getting a normal hit (which is basically 1st column - 2nd column). The 4th column represents estimated damage output, ie (Chance to get a critical hit * average damage * 2) + (Chance to get a normal hit * average damage). For the greatsword, with Improved critical, you need to hit on a 17 (20%) or more to get a chance of getting a critical hit. Your chance of getting a critical hit is (Chance to hit)² if your to-hit probability (1st column) is < 25%; and 20%*(Chance to hit) if your to-hit probability is > 20%. For the falchion, with Improved critical, you need to hit on a 15 (30%) or more to get a chance of getting a critical hit. Your chance of getting a critical hit is (Chance to hit)² if your to-hit probability (1st column) is < 35%; and 30%*(Chance to hit) if your to-hit probability is > 30%. I hope the tables are ok... [code] Greatsword (crit 17-20, ave dam 7+2+10 = 19, ave crit dam 38) %ToHit %Crit %Normal Ave dam 0,0% 0,0% 0,0% 0,00 5,0% 0,3% 4,8% 1,00 10,0% 1,0% 9,0% 2,09 15,0% 2,3% 12,8% 3,28 20,0% 4,0% 16,0% 4,56 25,0% 5,0% 20,0% 5,70 30,0% 6,0% 24,0% 6,84 35,0% 7,0% 28,0% 7,98 40,0% 8,0% 32,0% 9,12 45,0% 9,0% 36,0% 10,26 50,0% 10,0% 40,0% 11,40 55,0% 11,0% 44,0% 12,54 60,0% 12,0% 48,0% 13,68 65,0% 13,0% 52,0% 14,82 70,0% 14,0% 56,0% 15,96 75,0% 15,0% 60,0% 17,10 80,0% 16,0% 64,0% 18,24 85,0% 17,0% 68,0% 19,38 90,0% 18,0% 72,0% 20,52 95,0% 19,0% 76,0% 21,66 100,0% 20,0% 80,0% 22,80 Falchion (crit 15-20, ave dam 5+2+10 = 17, ave crit dam 34) %ToHit %Crit %Normal Ave dam 0,0% 0,0% 0,0% 0,00 5,0% 0,3% 4,8% 0,89 10,0% 1,0% 9,0% 1,87 15,0% 2,3% 12,8% 2,93 20,0% 4,0% 16,0% 4,08 25,0% 6,3% 18,8% 5,31 30,0% 9,0% 21,0% 6,63 35,0% 10,5% 24,5% 7,74 40,0% 12,0% 28,0% 8,84 45,0% 13,5% 31,5% 9,95 50,0% 15,0% 35,0% 11,05 55,0% 16,5% 38,5% 12,16 60,0% 18,0% 42,0% 13,26 65,0% 19,5% 45,5% 14,37 70,0% 21,0% 49,0% 15,47 75,0% 22,5% 52,5% 16,58 80,0% 24,0% 56,0% 17,68 85,0% 25,5% 59,5% 18,79 90,0% 27,0% 63,0% 19,89 95,0% 28,5% 66,5% 21,00 100,0% 30,0% 70,0% 22,10 [/code] Of course, any other input from other mathemagicians will be appreciated :) AR [/QUOTE]

Verification