Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Nagol" data-source="post: 5468518" data-attributes="member: 23935">I have very little interest in fan conflict and edition warring.&nbsp; I simply do not agree with the premise that all mutations of X still count as X regardless of degree of change.I don't have an issue with WotC dropping support for their previous editions other than I thought it had a very foolish rationale (removing legitimate sales channel reduces piracy? really?).&nbsp; I certainly never expected them to produce new material for those games.I do accept 4e is the current edition supported by the brand holder.&nbsp; But the experience I've had with 4e while certainly within my big tent of &quot;feels like fantasy roleplaying&quot; didn't fit in my smaller tent of &quot;feels like D&amp;D roleplaying&quot; to go back to a good metaphor I've seen on enworld before.&nbsp; Having someone say &quot;it's the same!&quot;&nbsp; means it's the same to them.&nbsp; Disputes start when they say &quot;It's the same and so it must be the same for you too!&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Nagol, post: 5468518, member: 23935"] I have very little interest in fan conflict and edition warring. I simply do not agree with the premise that all mutations of X still count as X regardless of degree of change. I don't have an issue with WotC dropping support for their previous editions other than I thought it had a very foolish rationale (removing legitimate sales channel reduces piracy? really?). I certainly never expected them to produce new material for those games. I do accept 4e is the current edition supported by the brand holder. But the experience I've had with 4e while certainly within my big tent of "feels like fantasy roleplaying" didn't fit in my smaller tent of "feels like D&D roleplaying" to go back to a good metaphor I've seen on enworld before. Having someone say "it's the same!" means it's the same to them. Disputes start when they say "It's the same and so it must be the same for you too!" [/QUOTE]

Verification