Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 5500840" data-attributes="member: 22779">Pawsplay - your post is just one in a host of posts really, and hardly the most egregious.&nbsp; I mean, it's not like you're claiming that it's the combination of unwritten rules and and assumptions that go beyond what's included in the 3e ruleset that makes 3e great.&nbsp; It's not you who's making drinking games out of things either.Sure, if we take a bunch of completely unprovable claims (what the unwritten intent of 3e is) and combine it with a lazer focused examination of ONLY what 4e claims and then try to compare editions, it's ultimately impossible.Sorry, I don't play BryonD&amp;D.&nbsp; I kinda wish I did, because it sounds interesting.&nbsp; But, when I post exact rules quotes, none of which have been refuted beyond, &quot;Well, a good DM just won't use those rules, why aren't you a good DM&quot;, and, if I stray a single syllable beyond the RAW of 4e I get monkey piled, why would I think that there is anything of value going to come from this conversation?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 5500840, member: 22779"] Pawsplay - your post is just one in a host of posts really, and hardly the most egregious. I mean, it's not like you're claiming that it's the combination of unwritten rules and and assumptions that go beyond what's included in the 3e ruleset that makes 3e great. It's not you who's making drinking games out of things either. Sure, if we take a bunch of completely unprovable claims (what the unwritten intent of 3e is) and combine it with a lazer focused examination of ONLY what 4e claims and then try to compare editions, it's ultimately impossible. Sorry, I don't play BryonD&D. I kinda wish I did, because it sounds interesting. But, when I post exact rules quotes, none of which have been refuted beyond, "Well, a good DM just won't use those rules, why aren't you a good DM", and, if I stray a single syllable beyond the RAW of 4e I get monkey piled, why would I think that there is anything of value going to come from this conversation? [/QUOTE]

Verification