Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mournblade94" data-source="post: 4627234" data-attributes="member: 74608">I ran a few months of 4th edition with friends of mine&nbsp; whom I have not gamed with since first edition D&amp;D.&nbsp; They were VERY enthusiastic about 4th.&nbsp; SO I agreed to run 4th edition.&nbsp;We did not make it through Keep on the Shadowfell, because it was a GRIND, and a very bad start for 4e which I was enthusiastic about but skeptical.&nbsp;So I ran soe scenarios.&nbsp; My enthusiastic Players soon got bored with 4e.&nbsp; They never played 3.5 and did not want to learn the system so I started running Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay.&nbsp; I continue to run that and 3.5 now.&nbsp;We found 4th edition to be a great tournament game but that is about all.&nbsp;I play with a very high roleplay intensive group.&nbsp; 4th edition just did not work for us.&nbsp; &nbsp;THe beauty of 4th edition:&nbsp; There are 3 other editions to play in if you do not like it.&nbsp;I do however use the skill challenge system from 4th edition for 3.5.&nbsp; I ahve always used skill chalenges, it is just nice to now have a designed set.&nbsp; They do it better than my house rules.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mournblade94, post: 4627234, member: 74608"] I ran a few months of 4th edition with friends of mine whom I have not gamed with since first edition D&D. They were VERY enthusiastic about 4th. SO I agreed to run 4th edition. We did not make it through Keep on the Shadowfell, because it was a GRIND, and a very bad start for 4e which I was enthusiastic about but skeptical. So I ran soe scenarios. My enthusiastic Players soon got bored with 4e. They never played 3.5 and did not want to learn the system so I started running Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay. I continue to run that and 3.5 now. We found 4th edition to be a great tournament game but that is about all. I play with a very high roleplay intensive group. 4th edition just did not work for us. THe beauty of 4th edition: There are 3 other editions to play in if you do not like it. I do however use the skill challenge system from 4th edition for 3.5. I ahve always used skill chalenges, it is just nice to now have a designed set. They do it better than my house rules. [/QUOTE]

Verification