Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Remathilis" data-source="post: 7390289" data-attributes="member: 7635">They all fit fine if we use the 3e and 4e versions as well. A version of DS that pulls from all editions for a version of D&amp;D that pulls from all editions; how novel! Paizo and WotC had no problems justifying all 11 3e classes in Dark Sun; sure, some of them were rare (paladin, monk, caster-bard) but they were all available. 4e might have restricted divine classes (mostly due to how power-sources worked in 4e) but they also had no problems with psionic monks or arcane bards. By my count, that's two editions that supported at least two-out-of-three of those classes. Which is my point; it'd be highly preferable to give advice on how to use all 12 PHB classes in Dark Sun (even if some are &quot;these are rare, check with DM&quot;) than to establish hard bans on these things. The same is true of the newer races like tieflings, goliaths, or dragonborn (the latter becoming half-giants and drays) rather than simply saying &quot;No, never evereverevereverevereverever!&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Remathilis, post: 7390289, member: 7635"] They all fit fine if we use the 3e and 4e versions as well. A version of DS that pulls from all editions for a version of D&D that pulls from all editions; how novel! Paizo and WotC had no problems justifying all 11 3e classes in Dark Sun; sure, some of them were rare (paladin, monk, caster-bard) but they were all available. 4e might have restricted divine classes (mostly due to how power-sources worked in 4e) but they also had no problems with psionic monks or arcane bards. By my count, that's two editions that supported at least two-out-of-three of those classes. Which is my point; it'd be highly preferable to give advice on how to use all 12 PHB classes in Dark Sun (even if some are "these are rare, check with DM") than to establish hard bans on these things. The same is true of the newer races like tieflings, goliaths, or dragonborn (the latter becoming half-giants and drays) rather than simply saying "No, never evereverevereverevereverever!" [/QUOTE]

Verification