Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="JeffB" data-source="post: 357877" data-attributes="member: 518">Psion,Come now...That was not meant as a &quot;slam&quot;.. merely the truth.&nbsp; The reviews here by the staff folks such as yourself and many others are quite good, and deserve merit, but they still are fan reviews, which other than picking apart on mechanics &quot;compliance level&quot;&nbsp; are highly subject to personal opinion/tastes. Of course you should take pride in your reviews, you work hard on them (as do other's) and do agreat job,&nbsp; but at the end of the day it's just one guy's (or gal's) opinion about a game-book; No more valid than the reviews at RPG.net, or anywhere else. ENWORLDS reviews might be the best out there, but they STILL are FAN reviews of game products. I don't see how adding HM reviews to the site will hurt anything, nor do I think it will &quot;tarnish&quot; reputations or &quot;credibility&quot;. If anything it's likely to sell a few more products fro Morrus, help inform some folks who may have been on the edge of buying/not buying, and it also just might make someone pick up a book, play the game and have some fun, which really is what it's all about whether the game is HM, 3E, SWD20, WoT, CoC, AD&amp;D, OD&amp;D, PLayer's Option or whatever else.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="JeffB, post: 357877, member: 518"] Psion, Come now...That was not meant as a "slam".. merely the truth. The reviews here by the staff folks such as yourself and many others are quite good, and deserve merit, but they still are fan reviews, which other than picking apart on mechanics "compliance level" are highly subject to personal opinion/tastes. Of course you should take pride in your reviews, you work hard on them (as do other's) and do agreat job, but at the end of the day it's just one guy's (or gal's) opinion about a game-book; No more valid than the reviews at RPG.net, or anywhere else. ENWORLDS reviews might be the best out there, but they STILL are FAN reviews of game products. I don't see how adding HM reviews to the site will hurt anything, nor do I think it will "tarnish" reputations or "credibility". If anything it's likely to sell a few more products fro Morrus, help inform some folks who may have been on the edge of buying/not buying, and it also just might make someone pick up a book, play the game and have some fun, which really is what it's all about whether the game is HM, 3E, SWD20, WoT, CoC, AD&D, OD&D, PLayer's Option or whatever else. [/QUOTE]

Verification